Imagine tuning into a thrilling NFL game, only to see player ratings from an analytics site splashed across your screen that leave you scratching your head—ratings that some of the game's greatest legends call outright nonsense. That's the fiery debate sparking in the football world right now, as former NFL stars are publicly ripping into the Pro Football Focus (PFF) grading system. But here's where it gets controversial: Are these 'made-up' numbers unfairly influencing how we see our favorite players, or is there real science behind the stats? Let's dive in and unpack this, step by step, so even newcomers to the sport can follow along.
Former NFL heavyweights like J.J. Watt, a five-time All-Pro defensive end who's now an analyst for CBS, and Chris Long, who logged 11 seasons in the league, have had it up to here with PFF's player rankings. They've been vocal about their frustration, especially after these grades appeared on the 'Sunday Night Football' broadcast during the Kansas City Chiefs' victory over the Detroit Lions earlier this week. For those unfamiliar, PFF is a popular website that dives deep into football analytics, breaking down plays and assigning numerical grades to players based on their performance. It's grown massively since its start, even expanding into college football, and NBC analyst Cris Collinsworth invested in it back in 2014. But for Watt and Long, it's not just the site they criticize—it's specifically the grading part.
Chris Long didn't hold back on his podcast, 'Green Light with Chris Long,' railing against seeing Patrick Mahomes rated as the league's 13th-best quarterback after his 13-of-32 passing performance. He joked—or was he serious?—about suing if he were a player like Derrick Nnadi, who might have 'earned' a bad grade this season. Long drew a wild comparison, saying he wants PFF scores yanked from TV screens as much as he wants political ads banned, arguing that these ratings could mislead casual viewers who might not recognize Mahomes's elite talent. And this is the part most people miss: Imagine being a kid or a new fan seeing '13' next to a Super Bowl winner—does that shape your perception unfairly?
J.J. Watt, while praising PFF's overall content as valuable, slammed the grading system as 'completely made up.' He shared stories from players who've told him about Uber drivers claiming to 'analyze' games for PFF just from watching TV broadcasts. Watt explained it simply: You can't accurately rate a player's performance without seeing the full picture, like their specific assignments, coaching schemes, and plays that aren't visible on air. As someone who knows defensive line play inside out, Watt insisted he couldn't assign a fair grade without that insider knowledge. It's a fact, he says, that makes you wonder—how reliable are these grades if pros like him think they're flawed?
But here's the twist that might divide fans: Some argue PFF grades add objectivity to a subjective sport, helping scouts and fans see beyond hype. Others, like Watt and Long, say they're arbitrary and potentially harmful. What do you think—should these analytics be banned from broadcasts, or do they enrich the viewing experience? And could this be a case of old-school players resisting new data-driven methods? Share your thoughts in the comments below; we'd love to hear if you're on Team PFF or siding with the former stars!
Speaking of making every NFL game payoff, why not turn your football passion into some real fun? Underdog (https://play.underdogfantasy.com/p-new-york-post) lets football enthusiasts compete and win big with simple player selections and no long-term commitments—prizes available every night. Sign up with promo code NYPOST5 to snag $50 in site credits after playing just $5! Remember, you must be 18+ (or 19+ in AL and NE; 19+ in CO for certain games, and 21+ in AZ and MA) and in a state where Underdog is active. If gambling concerns you, reach out to 1-800-GAMBLER or check http://www.ncpgambling.org. In NY, contact the 24/7 HOPEline at 1-877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369). The New York Post earns from affiliate and ad partnerships for sharing this, and the promo might differ by area.
